[Question] Which one is better ?

Here's the result of a really boring and snowing afternoon !


[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

OR

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

They are both 50+ layers photoshop files and since i'm a newb with photoshop, they represent 2 hours of work and they are inspired from several tuts i saw. but it's not really a success: the flames are fucked up in the first image, and something is wrong with the second one dunno what =x

Since i had to put the same effort in both, i can't decide which one is better (or worse), so choose for me !


UPDATED

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

I personally prefer the second one. I find the flames a little much in the first image, but keep workin at it, your work is much better than most people could ever dream of doing. XD

I wish it was my and only my work =o

But as i said i followed some tuts to do the techniques here

You can find the tuto for the first steps of the 2nd image, i customized it a bit at the end, only that



I just followed the instructions for the main part, changed a bit the settings, only that ^^ credit to those masters of photoshop , i'm learning plenty of techniques thanks to them

UPDATED

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

Waa there's so many possibilities, i'm really starting to enjoy photoshop

I really like the second one.